Giants Trim The Beard

With negotiations on a new deal at a stand still, the Giants are set to allow former all star closer Brian Wilson become a free agent. Coming off a second Tommy John surgery, and not expected to pitch until June at the earliest, Brian Wilson and the Giants are at an impasse in negotiations. The deadline to get something done is today and it would be a miracle if that happens.

After the emergence of Sergio Romo as the teams closer for much of the second half and the entire postseason, Wilson would probably not return to the closer role if he does pitch for the Giants again. Unfortunately the beloved bearded wonder lost his job to injury. Depth and perseverance got the Giants through the loss of the icon. However, let's not take for granted the impact that his presence had on Romo this past season.

While many fans feel Romo is ready to step into the role full time after another spectacular season, I have my reservations. He certainly is great but he is far from a conventional closer and I am concerned about how well he would do the job for a full season. If you think that I am the only one, remember that Santiago Casilla was the original replacement when Wilson went under the knife this time. Obviously, Bochy was not ready to give the reigns to Romo.

Don't get me wrong, once he got the ball he ran with it and did a spectacular job as the man. Romo was 14 out of 15 in save chances in the regular season and perfect in the postseason, while allowing just one run in the playoffs. I am certainly not the first to doubt Romo and he is a man who thrives on his doubters as much as his supporters. As fun loving as Romo seems, he competes hard and it is apparent that he is adamant about proving his doubters wrong. You can never question his heart or competitiveness.

If, or more likely when, Wilson becomes a free agent, I am hopeful that the two sides will continue to talk. A deal can still get done, it just opens up to competition from other clubs. Wilson is an icon in San Francisco and it would be a shame to see his time here end this way. Clearly, he wants to stay and that is a good thing. The issue is not really a dollar figure as much as it is about respect for what he has done for this team and in the community. While the world saw how great and entertaining he was in 2010, we all enjoyed him long before that. He is a staple on this club and I am really hoping that this all gets worked out soon.